I believe that most retirees who come to us with an accountant think they must pay quarterly taxes. But it depends. Below is a three-step framework to simplify your tax life in retirement.
1. Withhold Taxes Where You Can
Income from pensions, retirement plans, deferred comp, and Social Security can, and often should, have taxes withheld. The mistake I see most people make in the first three income streams is that they default to whatever the plan default is. If that matches your tax liability, it’s dumb luck.
When it comes to Social Security, withholding taxes seems to be the exception because it is not required when claiming. To withhold taxes from Social Security, you must fill out a W-4V. You may think you are withholding taxes based on the amounts that are deducted for Medicare before the money hits your bank account. Unfortunately, that misconception may result in an unpleasant April surprise.
There are two advantages to withholding taxes: First, it’s easier. If you’ve ever written a quarterly estimated tax payment, you know that withholding is just an easier way to get your money to the IRS. The second is important and less known. Taxes paid via withholding are considered to be prorated across the calendar year. Therefore, you don’t need to worry about quarterly deadlines and the penalties associated with missing them, as long as your total payments satisfy applicable IRS requirements.
2. Project the Total Tax Liability
We rely on a suite of technology to project current and future tax rates for our clients. I am fully aware that running a tax projection, given the complexity of our tax code, is not simple. That said, the IRS has a few tools, as does DIY tax software. If you use an accountant, they should be able to do this for you.
Most tax preparers will base your quarterly estimates on last year’s liability. They want to “penalty-proof” your payments. This is a way to avoid underpayment penalties assessed by the IRS. You can do this by paying either of the following amounts (the $150,000 threshold is based on prior-year adjusted gross income, or $75,000 if married filing separately):
| Prior-Year AGI | Under $150k | Over $150k |
|---|---|---|
| Option 1 | 90% of the current year liability | 90% of the current year liability |
| Option 2 | 100% of your total liability last year | 110% of your total liability last year |
However, making sure you don’t pay a penalty is not the same as running a tax projection. In an ideal world, you can make an estimate that says, “This year I expect to pay about $______ in taxes.” With an emphasis on “about.”
3. Pay the Difference Through Estimated Payments
If you can say, “I think my total tax liability will be $45,000, and I’ve already withheld $25,000,” then you are going to pay the $20,000 gap via estimated payments. However, taxes in the U.S. are on a “pay-as-you-go” system, so you may not be paying $5,000 per quarter. You would make the quarterly payment in the quarter that income was received. Each quarter has a due date for the associated tax liability.
Federal Estimated Payment Due Dates
| Quarter | Due Date |
|---|---|
| 1st Quarter | April 15, current year |
| 2nd Quarter | June 15, current year |
| 3rd Quarter | September 15, current year |
| 4th Quarter | January 15, next year |
It’s important to note that estimated payment due dates vary by state and will not always line up with the federal due date. Most retirees are in the habit of paying by check, but the IRS has made the online process fairly straightforward.
All the information above is tactical in nature. It is simply a framework to make sure you aren’t writing a big check, unexpectedly, in April. None of it is strategic. A strategic plan entails not only making sure that your bills are getting paid but also looking at current rates vs. future rates to come up with a plan to minimize your lifetime tax bill. That article can be found here: How to Keep More of Your Money in Retirement.
This article is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as tax, investment, or legal advice. The framework described is general in nature and may not be appropriate for every taxpayer. Withholding rules, safe-harbor thresholds, and estimated payment due dates reflect federal rules as of the date of publication, are subject to change, and may differ under state law; due dates may also shift when they fall on a weekend or holiday. Tax projections are estimates based on assumptions that may not occur, and actual tax liability may differ. Meeting a safe-harbor threshold may avoid underpayment penalties but may not satisfy your full tax liability for the year. Links to third-party websites are provided for convenience only, and we are not responsible for their content. Consult your tax advisor regarding your withholding and estimated tax payments.